Malpractice Policy

ESUF, published by Researcher Publishers, addresses concerns about research integrity and publication ethics through fair assessment of the available evidence, with reference to relevant COPE guidance. This policy explains prohibited practices, how concerns are assessed, and the editorial actions available to protect the scholarly record. Allegations will be distinguished from established findings, and information will be handled in accordance with the confidentiality provisions below.

Forms of Publication Malpractice

1. Plagiarism and Copyright Infringement

ESUF prohibits presenting the words, ideas, data, images, or other work of others as original without appropriate acknowledgement. This includes unattributed copying, close paraphrasing, combining copied passages from multiple sources, and translating material without acknowledging the original source. Direct quotations must be clearly identified and cited. Paraphrased material must accurately represent the source and include appropriate attribution.

Authors must obtain permission for reused material where required and comply with any applicable licence conditions. A citation does not, by itself, establish permission to reproduce copyrighted material.

Manuscripts may be screened using text-similarity and duplication-checking tools. Similarity reports support editorial assessment but do not, by themselves, establish plagiarism. Editors will consider the matched passages, attribution, quotation practices, and context. A low similarity score does not establish originality, and a high score does not automatically establish misconduct.

Suspected plagiarism or unauthorised reuse will be assessed under the investigation procedures below. Authors may be asked to explain overlapping material or provide source and permission records.

2. Duplicate and Redundant Publication

Manuscripts submitted to ESUF must not be under consideration by another journal or publication outlet. Duplicate or substantially overlapping publication without appropriate disclosure is prohibited. Authors must not divide substantially overlapping findings into separate papers in a way that misrepresents their originality or contribution.

Authors must disclose related publications, manuscripts under consideration elsewhere, and any earlier dissemination of the submitted work, including repository postings, preprints, theses, conference abstracts, or conference papers. Provide references or links where available and explain the relationship between the earlier material and the submission, including the substantive contribution of the submitted manuscript.

Disclosure does not itself establish eligibility for publication. Where earlier dissemination may affect the requirement for previously unpublished work, authors should seek clarification from the editorial office before submitting. Editors will assess the extent of overlap, originality, attribution, and any relevant copyright or permission requirements.

Reused text, figures, tables, or other material must be appropriately attributed, with permission obtained where required. Undisclosed overlap or misleading claims of originality may lead to editorial action under this policy.

3. Fabrication and Falsification

ESUF prohibits inventing data, research activities, results, citations, or references and presenting them as genuine. Falsification includes altering or omitting data, manipulating images, or misrepresenting research procedures in ways that give a misleading account of the research or its findings.

Data cleaning, exclusions, transformations, and image adjustments must be scientifically justified and transparently reported where relevant to understanding or evaluating the work. Authors must not conceal findings, methodological changes, or limitations in ways that materially distort the conclusions.

Honest errors and differences in interpretation do not, by themselves, establish fabrication or falsification. Errors that affect the accuracy or reliability of submitted or published work must nevertheless be reported to the editorial office and addressed through appropriate editorial action.

ESUF may request original data, analysis records, image files, protocols, or other supporting documentation when assessing a concern. Authors must explain any restrictions on sharing these materials and cooperate with reasonable requests while protecting participant confidentiality and complying with applicable consent and data-protection requirements.

4. Authorship Misconduct

ESUF prohibits guest, honorary, or gift authorship, the omission of individuals who qualify for authorship, and the inclusion of anyone as an author without their knowledge and agreement. Authors must accurately describe their contributions and approve the submitted manuscript. Contributor statements or written authorship confirmations may be requested where clarification is needed.

Requests to add or remove an author, or change the order of authors after submission, must be sent to the editorial office with an explanation and written agreement from all affected authors, including anyone being added or removed. Changes require editorial approval and must not be made solely by altering the manuscript or submission metadata. Approved changes after publication will be documented through an appropriate correction.

An authorship dispute does not, by itself, establish misconduct. Where the individuals concerned cannot agree, review or publication may be paused while the dispute is referred to the relevant institution or other responsible body. ESUF will assess the implications for the submission or published article but will not adjudicate unresolved disputes over entitlement to authorship.

5. Peer Review Misconduct

ESUF prohibits fabricated reviewer identities, fraudulent reviewer accounts, coordinated attempts to manipulate peer review, and interference with independent editorial assessment. Authors must not impersonate reviewers, provide false reviewer contact details, or arrange favourable reviews through undisclosed agreements.

Reviewers and editors must disclose relevant competing interests and decline or withdraw from an assessment when impartiality cannot be maintained. Confidential manuscripts, review reports, and unpublished information must not be shared without authorisation or used for personal advantage. Reviewers must obtain editorial approval before involving another person in a review.

Review recommendations must reflect an independent assessment of the work. Coercion, retaliation, and requests for personal or professional benefits in exchange for a favourable recommendation are prohibited. Suspected breaches will be assessed under the investigation procedures below.

6. Citation Manipulation

References must be selected for their relevance to the research and must accurately represent the cited work. Citation of previous work by the same authors is appropriate when it contributes to the scholarly context, methods, or interpretation. Citations must not be added primarily to inflate citation counts or promote particular authors, journals, or institutions.

ESUF prohibits coercive citation requests, coordinated citation exchanges intended to manipulate metrics, and the inclusion of irrelevant references for non-scholarly purposes. Authors must not deliberately misrepresent sources or omit relevant evidence in a way that distorts the scholarly context.

Editors and reviewers who recommend additional references should explain their relevance. Authors may explain why a suggested reference is not appropriate and raise concerns about citation pressure with the editorial office through the complaints procedure below. Acceptance must not depend on adding citations that lack a scholarly justification.

7. Misuse of Artificial Intelligence

AI and automated tools may support technical and linguistic manuscript preparation, including grammar checking, translation assistance, formatting, and improving the clarity and organisation of author-generated content. Such assistance must be disclosed and must not replace the intellectual contribution, analysis, interpretation, arguments, or conclusions of the authors.

Misuse includes fabricating research data, findings, citations, or references; concealing material use of AI tools; generating fraudulent or deceptive submissions; manipulating peer review; or uploading confidential manuscripts, unpublished data, or other protected materials into external systems without appropriate authorisation and safeguards.

Legitimate use of AI as part of the research methodology must be academically justified and described in the Methods section, including the tools, procedures, validation, and human oversight where applicable. This is distinct from using AI to invent or misrepresent research findings.

Every submission must include an AI Tool Use statement in the separate Declaration file, including an explicit statement when no AI-assisted tools were used in manuscript preparation. AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Authors remain responsible for verifying all submitted content. Failure to disclose material AI use, or use that compromises the accuracy, originality, or integrity of the work, may constitute publication malpractice.

8. Misinformation and Disinformation

Authors must communicate findings accurately and in proportion to the evidence. ESUF prohibits knowingly presenting false or misleading research claims, concealing material limitations or contradictory evidence, and selectively presenting findings in ways that materially distort their meaning. These requirements apply to text, tables, figures, datasets, and AI-assisted material.

Honest errors, uncertainty, and reasonable differences in scholarly interpretation do not, by themselves, establish deliberate deception. Authors should acknowledge relevant limitations, distinguish evidence from speculation, and correct material errors brought to their attention. Concerns about misleading content will be assessed on the available evidence under the investigation procedures below.

9. Ethical and Regulatory Non-Compliance

Authors must comply with the ethical, institutional, and legal requirements applicable to their research. Ethical breaches include conducting research without required ethics approval or informed consent, mistreating research participants or animals, violating privacy or confidentiality, failing to disclose relevant competing interests, and disregarding applicable institutional or funding requirements.

Where ethics approval or informed consent was not required, authors must explain the basis in the Ethics Approval and Informed Consent section of the separate Declaration file. Where an exemption or waiver was granted, identify the responsible body and provide the reference or supporting documentation where available. Authors must not present an exemption, waiver, or approval as having been granted unless it was obtained.

ESUF may request clarification or supporting documentation when assessing compliance. Authors should provide such material through the editorial office and avoid including identifiable participant information unless necessary and appropriately authorised. Concerns will be assessed under the investigation procedures below.

Authors who wish to appeal an editorial decision should contact the editorial office through the Contact page, providing the manuscript title, submission ID, and a reasoned explanation of the appeal. The explanation should identify any factual errors, misunderstandings, or procedural concerns and include supporting evidence where available. An appeal does not guarantee further review or reversal of the decision.

Complaints about editorial conduct, peer review, publication ethics, or the handling of a submission should also be sent to the editorial office. Please describe the concern, identify the submission or published article where applicable, and provide relevant correspondence or other evidence. State clearly whether you are requesting reconsideration of an editorial decision or reporting a concern about conduct or procedure.

Appeals and complaints will be assessed by an editor without a relevant competing interest. Where a complaint concerns the handling editor, another editor or a representative of the publisher will oversee its consideration. The person raising the matter will be informed of the outcome and the principal reasons, subject to confidentiality requirements.

Investigations of Misconduct

Concerns about possible misconduct may be raised by authors, reviewers, editors, institutions, readers, or other parties. The editorial office will assess the information provided and distinguish allegations from established findings. Where appropriate, the individuals concerned will be informed of the substance of the allegation and given an opportunity to respond and provide relevant evidence.

Editorial assessment may include requests for explanations, supporting records, or original research materials, and consultation with independent experts. Review or publication may be paused while a concern is assessed. Information will be handled in accordance with the confidentiality provisions below.

Where a concern requires a formal investigation into research conduct, ESUF may refer the matter to the relevant institution, research ethics body, or other responsible organisation and cooperate with its investigation. Editorial assessment does not replace an institutional investigation. ESUF remains responsible for decisions about submitted manuscripts and the accuracy and integrity of the published record.

Editorial action will reflect the available evidence and the nature and seriousness of the concern. The individuals concerned will be informed of the outcome and the principal reasons, subject to confidentiality requirements. Unresolved concerns may warrant an expression of concern, as described below, without being presented as confirmed misconduct.

Editorial Actions and Sanctions

ESUF may reject a submitted manuscript or withdraw acceptance before publication where the available evidence warrants that action. For published articles, corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions will be considered under the provisions below. These measures protect the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record and do not necessarily imply misconduct.

Where misconduct is established, further action may include restrictions on future submissions or removal from reviewer or editorial responsibilities. Any restriction will be proportionate to the seriousness and circumstances of the case. The individuals concerned will be informed of the reasons and, where applicable, the scope and duration of the restriction, and may appeal through the procedure described above.

Relevant concerns or findings may be referred to institutions, funding bodies, or other responsible organisations where appropriate. Any legal action would be considered separately by the publisher with appropriate legal advice.

Retractions and Corrections

ESUF will correct the published record when errors or ethical concerns require action. A correction may be issued when an error affects part of an article but does not invalidate the main findings or conclusions. Authors and readers should report suspected errors to the editorial office, identifying the article and providing relevant details or evidence.

Retraction may be necessary when there is clear evidence that findings are unreliable because of major error, fabrication, or falsification, or when plagiarism, redundant publication, compromised peer review, or serious ethical breaches undermine the integrity of the publication. Retraction serves to correct the scholarly record and does not, by itself, establish misconduct by every author.

An expression of concern may be issued when substantial concerns remain unresolved or an investigation is ongoing. The notice will explain the concern and will be followed by an update, correction, or retraction as appropriate when further evidence becomes available.

Corrections, expressions of concern, and retraction notices will be freely accessible, identify the affected article, explain the reasons for the action, and link to the article. Retracted articles will normally remain available and be clearly marked as retracted. Any exceptional removal of content will be accompanied by a notice explaining the reason as far as possible.

Confidentiality and Whistleblower Protection

ESUF will handle allegations and investigations confidentially as far as reasonably possible. Information will be shared only where necessary to assess the concern, obtain a response, conduct an investigation, or meet applicable legal requirements. People reporting concerns may request that their identity remain confidential. The editorial office will discuss any necessary disclosure with them where practicable, but cannot guarantee complete anonymity.

ESUF will not penalise individuals for raising concerns in good faith, even when an investigation does not substantiate an allegation. The journal cannot guarantee protection from actions taken by employers, institutions, or other third parties. Anonymous reports will be considered where they provide sufficient information to assess the concern.