For Reviewers

The Journal of Education for Sustainable Futures (ESUF) relies on the commitment and expertise of our editors and reviewers to maintain the high standards and academic integrity of the Journal. As a reviewer, your role is not only crucial to the advancement of scholarship in sustainability education but also to supporting the development of individual authors by providing constructive and professional feedback. Below are the key expectations we have for our reviewers to ensure the peer-review process is rigorous, ethical, and fair.

Relevant Subject and Methodological Expertise
Reviewers should have expertise in education for sustainable futures or the research methods relevant to the manuscript. They should assess the originality, theoretical grounding, methodological rigour, clarity, and contribution of the work within the aims and scope of ESUF. Reviewers who cannot adequately assess an important aspect of a submission should inform the handling editor.

Fairness and Objectivity
Reviewers should assess manuscripts fairly and base their recommendations on originality, clarity, methodology, relevance, and scholarly contribution. Before accepting an invitation, reviewers must disclose any actual or potential competing interests to the handling editor, including relevant personal, professional, institutional, or financial relationships. If uncertain whether an interest could affect impartiality, seek advice from the editor before proceeding. Reviewers who cannot provide an impartial assessment should decline the invitation. Any competing interest discovered after accepting must be reported promptly so that the editor can decide how to proceed.

Ethical Responsibility
Reviewers must provide honest, respectful, and constructive assessments and keep manuscripts and review materials confidential. Report suspected plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other ethical concerns promptly and privately to the handling editor, identifying the relevant passages or evidence where possible. Do not present suspicions as established findings, investigate independently, or contact the authors directly without permission from the editor. Do not share the manuscript or involve another person in the review without prior approval from the editor. Information obtained through peer review must not be used for personal advantage or for the benefit of others.

Constructive and Justifiable Feedback
Reviewers should provide specific, constructive comments supported by examples from the manuscript. Distinguish concerns that affect the validity or contribution of the research from minor corrections and optional suggestions. Explain the reasons for recommending acceptance, revision, or rejection, and keep comments professional and focused on the work. When recommending additional references, explain their relevance and provide enough bibliographic information for authors to identify them. Do not request citations merely to increase citation counts or promote particular authors, journals, or institutions. The final editorial decision rests with the editor.

Timeliness and Commitment
Timeliness is a key expectation for reviewers. We understand that the review process is voluntary; however, prompt feedback is critical to maintaining the publication schedule of the Journal. We ask that reviewers complete their assessments within the agreed timeframe. If circumstances arise that prevent you from meeting the deadline, it is important to notify the editorial team as soon as possible to avoid delays. Being responsive and communicative demonstrates professionalism and respect for the authors, editors, and the broader academic community.

Contribution to the Academic Community
By serving as a reviewer, you are contributing to the advancement of knowledge within the field of Education for Sustainable Futures. Your participation helps shape the direction of research and practice in the field, ensuring that innovative, impactful, and methodologically sound studies reach the academic community. This role provides an opportunity to give back to the Education for Sustainable Futures community, foster collaboration, and promote scholarly excellence.

Recognition of Contributions
While the role of a reviewer is voluntary, ESUF deeply values the time, effort, and expertise you contribute. To recognize your contributions, we provide official certificates of recognition upon the completion of your reviews. Additionally, we acknowledge the critical role that reviewers play in maintaining the quality of the journal and fostering an environment of rigorous academic exchange.

Reviewer Identity in MS Word
Before adding comments or tracked changes, configure Microsoft Word to use a neutral reviewer name, such as “Reviewer.” In desktop Word for Windows, open File > Options > General and update the User name and Initials under Personalize your copy of Microsoft Office. Where available, select “Always use these values regardless of sign in to Office.” Menu options may differ between versions and platforms.

Changing these settings alone does not establish that the completed file is anonymous. Before uploading, save a separate copy and check the filename, document properties, comments, tracked changes, headers, and footers for identifying information. In Word for Windows, use File > Info > Check for Issues > Inspect Document to inspect the copy and remove personal information as appropriate. Preserve the review comments and tracked changes needed by the authors. Save, close, and reopen the file to confirm that the feedback remains intact and identifying information is no longer visible. If you cannot anonymise the file without losing feedback, contact the handling editor before uploading it.

Confidentiality and AI Tools

Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and review materials. Manuscripts, unpublished data, figures, review reports, and other confidential information must not be uploaded to external AI systems where confidentiality and data protection cannot be assured.

Any permitted use of AI must comply with the AI policy of Researcher Publishers and the Academic Integrity policy of ESUF. AI assistance must not replace the reviewer’s independent scholarly assessment. Reviewers remain responsible for the accuracy, reasoning, and integrity of their reports.

ESUF welcomes prospective reviewers with expertise in education for sustainable futures or relevant research methods. To express interest, register with the journal, select “Yes, I would like to be contacted with requests to review submissions to this journal,” and complete the Reviewing interests field with your topics of expertise. Keep these topics up to date in your account by adding or modifying them as your research interests and expertise develop. If you already have an account, update your reviewing interests and contact the editorial office to express interest. Review invitations depend on the subject and methodological requirements of individual manuscripts.