ISSN: xxxx-xxxx | Access: Open
Licence: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Frequency: Biannual (Jun & Dec)
Academic Integrity
ESUF expects authors, reviewers, and editors to uphold academic integrity, transparency, accountability, and responsible scholarly communication. This policy sets out their responsibilities for submitted and published work, with reference to relevant COPE guidance and applicable ethical and legal requirements. It should be read together with the Ethics Policy and Malpractice Policy of ESUF.
Principles of Integrity
Authors, editors, reviewers, editorial board members, and publisher representatives are expected to act honestly, fairly, and responsibly. Research and reporting must be accurate, sources appropriately acknowledged, and methods, contributions, funding, and competing interests transparently described.
All participants must respect confidentiality, intellectual property, and the rights and welfare of research participants. Scholarly claims must reflect the available evidence, acknowledge relevant limitations, and distinguish findings from interpretation or speculation. Concerns and errors should be addressed through the procedures set out in the relevant ESUF policies.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of all submitted content. Manuscripts must not be under consideration by another journal or publication outlet. Related publications and earlier dissemination must be disclosed in accordance with the Malpractice Policy.
Data, methods, analyses, findings, and conclusions must be reported accurately and transparently. Sources must be acknowledged, quotations clearly identified, and references checked against the original sources. Permission for reused material must be obtained where required.
All listed authors must have made contributions that qualify them for authorship and must approve the submitted manuscript. Contributions must be accurately described. Contributors who do not qualify for authorship should be acknowledged with their agreement. Requests to change authorship must follow the procedure in the Malpractice Policy.
Authors must disclose relevant funding, sponsor involvement, and financial or non-financial competing interests. Ethics approval and informed consent must be obtained where required, with any exemption, waiver, or non-applicability explained in the separate Declaration file. Authors must cooperate with reasonable requests for clarification or supporting records while protecting confidential and personal information.
Editorial Independence and Editorial Responsibility
Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly quality, originality, methodological rigour, ethical compliance, the reliability of the evidence, and relevance to the aims and scope of ESUF. Commercial interests, donations, institutional relationships, and personal considerations must not determine acceptance or rejection.
Editors must disclose relevant competing interests and withdraw from handling a manuscript when impartiality could reasonably be questioned. Submissions involving an editor as an author, or another relationship that creates a competing interest, must be assigned to an editor without that conflict. The individual concerned must not influence reviewer selection, assessment, or the publication decision.
Editors must protect confidential information, oversee fair peer review, and address integrity concerns through the procedures in the Malpractice Policy. Editorial independence does not remove accountability: decisions and complaints remain subject to the review and appeal procedures described in that policy.
Peer Review Integrity
Reviewers must assess manuscripts fairly and provide specific, constructive comments supported by scholarly reasons. They must disclose competing interests, accept assignments only when they have suitable expertise and sufficient time, and inform the handling editor if circumstances prevent completion.
Manuscripts, review reports, and unpublished information must remain confidential. Reviewers must obtain editorial approval before involving another person and must not use information obtained through review for personal advantage. Suspected ethical concerns should be reported privately to the handling editor with relevant evidence where available.
Fabricated reviewer identities, fraudulent accounts, coordinated review manipulation, coercive citation requests, and other attempts to compromise independent assessment are prohibited. Further responsibilities are set out in the For Reviewers guidance and the Malpractice Policy.
Declaration Requirements
Every submission must include a separate Declaration file, completed using the journal template. Authors must complete all six sections:
- Ethics Approval and Informed Consent
- AI Tool Use
- Funding
- Conflicts of Interest
- Data Availability
- Author Contributions
Select and adapt the statements that accurately describe the work. Remove unused scenarios and instructional text, replace all placeholders, and explain when a declaration is not applicable.
For research involving human participants, provide the applicable ethics approval and informed consent information. If formal approval or consent was not required, explain the basis under the relevant institutional requirements or determination. Authors must not claim approval, exemption, or consent without supporting grounds.
Disclose funding sources and relevant financial or non-financial conflicts of interest, including editorial roles with the journal or publisher. State explicitly when no funding or conflicts apply. Explain where supporting data can be accessed and any restrictions on sharing. Describe each author’s actual contribution.
Keep author-identifying declaration details in the separate Declaration file. The manuscript intended for double-blind review must retain the information needed to evaluate the research while anonymising details that could reveal author identities. Follow the Author Guidelines when preparing these files.
Data Integrity and Transparency
Authors should maintain accurate research records and retain supporting data and documentation in accordance with applicable institutional, funder, ethical, and legal requirements. Records should be sufficient to explain and, where appropriate, verify the reported methods and findings.
Where ethically and legally possible, authors are encouraged to share supporting data, research instruments, and analytical materials through an appropriate repository. The Data Availability statement must explain where materials can be accessed, any conditions or restrictions, or why sharing is not possible. Authors must not promise access that they cannot provide.
Participant confidentiality, informed consent, intellectual property, and contractual restrictions must be respected. Where no new data were generated or analysed, authors should state that data sharing is not applicable.
Artificial Intelligence and Automated Tools
ESUF follows the Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) Tools policy of Researcher Publishers.
AI tools may support technical and linguistic manuscript preparation, including grammar checking, translation assistance, formatting, and improving the clarity and organisation of author-generated content. Such assistance must preserve the authors’ meaning and scholarly contribution.
AI tools must not replace the authors’ intellectual contribution, analysis, interpretation, arguments, or conclusions. They must not be used to fabricate research data, findings, citations, or references. Authors must independently check citations and references against their original sources.
Legitimate use of AI as part of a research methodology must be academically justified and described in the Methods section. Include sufficient information about the tools, versions where available, procedures, validation, and human oversight for readers to evaluate their use.
Every submission must include an AI Tool Use statement in the separate Declaration file. Where AI-assisted tools were used in manuscript preparation, identify the tools and versions where available, explain their purpose and extent of use, identify the affected sections or materials, and confirm that the authors reviewed and verified the output.
Where no AI or AI-assisted tools were used in manuscript preparation, state:
No AI or AI-assisted tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.
AI systems cannot be listed as authors. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and ethical compliance of all submitted content.
Authors, reviewers, and editors must protect confidential information, personal data, and intellectual property when using external tools. Reviewers and editors must not upload manuscripts, unpublished data, or confidential review materials to external AI systems where confidentiality and data protection cannot be assured.
Suspected misuse or failure to disclose material AI use will be assessed under the Malpractice Policy.
Responsible Reporting and Scholarly Communication
Authors must present findings and interpretations in proportion to the evidence. Relevant limitations and contradictory findings should be acknowledged, and conclusions must not extend beyond what the research can support. The same care should be taken when describing the research in abstracts, summaries, or public communications.
Fabricated claims, deceptive presentation of evidence, and deliberate concealment of information that materially affects interpretation are prohibited. Honest errors and reasonable differences in interpretation do not, by themselves, establish misconduct. Material errors should be reported to the editorial office and addressed under the Malpractice Policy.
Ethics Approval and Informed Consent
Research involving human participants, personal or sensitive data, animals, or other ethically sensitive contexts must comply with applicable ethical and legal requirements. Authors must obtain ethics approval and informed consent where required and describe the measures used to protect participants, confidentiality, and animal welfare where relevant.
The separate Declaration file must identify the approving body and approval reference where applicable, describe the consent arrangements, and explain any exemption, waiver, or basis for approval or consent not being required. Supporting documentation may be requested. Authors must not claim approval, exemption, waiver, or consent without supporting grounds.
Consent to participate in research must not be assumed to include consent to publish identifiable information. Authors must ensure that any such publication has the necessary consent and authorisation. The manuscript used for double-blind review must retain sufficient information to assess the research while anonymising details that could reveal author identities, as explained in the Author Guidelines.
Protection of the Scholarly Record
ESUF will assess reported errors and integrity concerns and take appropriate action to maintain an accurate scholarly record. Honest errors will be distinguished from deliberate misconduct. Depending on the evidence, action may include a correction, expression of concern, or retraction.
Notices will identify the affected article, explain the reasons for the action, and link to the article in accordance with the Malpractice Policy. Authors, reviewers, and readers should report material concerns to the editorial office through the Contact page. The procedures for investigations, complaints, appeals, and post-publication action are provided in the Malpractice Policy.







